
Brought to you by Institute for Performance Management:
Who uses the flexibility your company offers? Look at the numbers and the answer is mostly women.
Women made up 47% of the US workforce in 2023, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, yet 59% of the people working part time. Among workers aged 25 to 54 the share rose to 61%. Among people who teleworked, women did so for a larger share of their working hours than men.
McKinsey and LeanIn.org’s Women in the Workplace 2023 report found that 38% of mothers with young children would have had to leave their company or cut their hours without flexibility. A year earlier, the same study found only one woman in 10 wanted to work mostly on-site.
Flexibility keeps talented women in work. The question is what happens to them when the annual review comes round.
The Penalty for Not Being Seen
Nicholas Bloom and colleagues ran a nine-month experiment at Ctrip, a large Chinese travel company, published in the Quarterly Journal of Economics. Call center staff who worked from home were 13% more productive than their office colleagues. Their promotion rate, once performance was taken into account, fell. The National Bureau of Economic Research put it at almost 50% lower, possibly because office-based managers simply didn’t see them.
Researchers at the University of Warsaw, Agnieszka Kasperska, Anna Matysiak and Ewa Cukrowska-Torzewska, found the same more recently. They asked 937 UK managers to judge fictional employees. With no performance information in front of them, managers were about 8% less likely to promote a hybrid worker than an identical colleague in the office, because they assumed the hybrid worker was performing worse. When the researchers supplied the performance data, the penalty for hybrid workers largely disappeared.
Hold on to that last finding. Proximity bias feeds on missing evidence, and it’s women who are most often missing from the room.
The Second Penalty: How Her Work Gets Written Up
Visibility is half the problem. The other half is what managers write about women when they do sit down to review them.
Shelley Correll and Caroline Simard of Stanford studied performance reviews at three technology companies and a professional services firm and reported their findings in Harvard Business Review. Women were less likely than men to get specific feedback tied to business outcomes, whether the feedback was praise or criticism. In developmental feedback the gap was stark: 60% of men’s comments were linked to outcomes, against 40% of women’s. Women were also more likely to get vague praise: 57% of them, against 43% of men.
Textio’s 2024 analysis of more than 23,000 reviews across 250 US workplaces shows the same from another angle. Women received 22% more feedback about their personality than men. Nearly a third of women were described as opinionated, compared with 4% of men.
Put the two penalties together and the picture gets worse. A manager who rarely sees a woman’s work has little specific to say about it. The gap fills up with adjectives. “Helpful.” “A great team player.” “Always positive.” “Could be more visible.” None of it will carry her through a promotion meeting.
Her Schedule Says Nothing About Her Ambition
Some managers read a flexible schedule as a signal that a woman has stepped back from her career. The evidence says otherwise. Women in the Workplace 2023 found that women working hybrid or remotely were just as ambitious as women and men on-site, and one in five women said flexibility had helped them stay in their job or keep their hours.
Treat flexibility as a lack of commitment and you misjudge your best people. You also widen what the same report calls the broken rung: in 2023, for every 100 men promoted to their first management role, only 87 women were.
Two Stars and a Spreadsheet
Picture a commercial team of nine, split between the office and home. At year end the two top ratings go to two office-based colleagues who presented the team’s biggest projects to senior leaders.
Priya, a remote analyst, is rated “meets expectations”. She built the pricing model behind one project and the demand forecast behind the other. Her objectives read “support project teams” and “be more visible to stakeholders”. Her check-ins happened roughly once a month. Nobody asked her colleagues what she contributed.
Priya’s rating was decided in January, when vague objectives rewarded visibility. Irregular check-ins and an empty record did the rest.
What Managers Can Change
Write objectives around outcomes that can be checked from anywhere. Scale part-time targets to the hours agreed instead of squeezing a full-time job into fewer days. Rate a woman’s performance with any agreed adjustment in place, and never treat using one as a development point.
Hold short, regular check-ins at protected times, on the same terms for everyone, and keep a running written note for each person. Use the same evidence sources for every team member, including peers and customers who see work you miss. Then read your draft reviews back and count the personality words against the outcomes.
Before any rating is final, ask yourself one question: Would I rate her the same if I had seen her every day?
Keep well-being conversations out of the rating too. A woman who tells you she is stretched by caring for a parent or a child should never find it waiting in her review.
If You’re the One Being Rated
You can protect yourself without waiting for your manager to read the research. Ask for your objectives in writing, framed as results. Keep your own dated record of what you delivered and who relied on it. Name the colleagues and customers who can speak to your work, and ask for their input to be gathered before ratings are set.
And when feedback comes back vague, ask the question Correll and Simard’s work points to: Which specific result made the difference, and what exactly would take me to the next level?
New in the Certificate in Performance Management
Obtaining a certificate in performance management can help you better understand proximity bias, outcome-based objectives, check-ins at a distance and fair evidence, including how to rate part-time staff and people with adjustments on the same terms as everyone else. The Institute for Performance Management’s online certificate in performance management course for supervisors and managers covers these topics and more.
Flexibility kept her in the workforce. A fair review keeps her on the way up.